Comment Comment
Comment on the blogs Log in here Become a member Register now
 
Rob MacLachlan

Rob MacLachlan

23 Mar 2010 | 10:08

(Maximum of 120 characters)
Articles more than one month old can be viewed only by CIPD members or PM Subscribers.


Is Britain in danger of adopting the French or Greek “strike-at-the-drop-of-a-hat” style of industrial relations? I say this with conscious irony, because those of us who witnessed the bitter disputes of the 1970s and ‘80s will recall that Britain then seemed to be the home of industrial anarchy. One infamous feature of our economic life even had a Mediterranean flavour: the “Spanish practices” that had nothing to do with Spain but were distinctively British.

Temperatures are certainly rising again. Recently People Management has reported on several actual or threatened strikes, including at BA, on the railways, at British Gas and in the civil service. The reasons include proposed job cuts, reduced levels of redundancy pay, even (at British Gas) an alleged culture of bullying. But if it wasn’t for the legal requirement to stage a strike ballot before taking industrial action, I suspect even more bush fires might be breaking out.

Significantly, most of the action is in the public sector, or in once-nationalised transport and utilities sectors that were privatised by the Tories in the 1980s but still retain a strong trade union tradition. These workers are fed up with the tightening of business discipline and gradual erosion of jobs during the recession or, in the public sector, anticipating slashed public spending and job cuts after the general election, whoever wins.

I wonder why all this is happening now. One explanation may be that the unions fear a more hostile political environment under an incoming Tory government. But I suspect the increasing resolution of many trade unionists is fuelled by anger at the “fat cat” behaviour of bankers, MPs and business leaders, including now, many council chief executives with their indefensible “golden goodbye” payments.

When ordinary decent working folk are continually hearing about people in leadership positions, or strategically powerful roles, playing the system to maximise their pay and rewards in sometimes spectacularly selfish ways, “just because they can”, isn’t it only natural that some are inclined to behave in the same way? I imagine that in organisations where there is still a strong public service ethic (in the widest sense) at the top, this grass-roots anger isn’t such a problem.

So some flexing of what used to be called industrial muscle is hardly surprising. And more HR people with an industrial relations remit may also need to exercise unaccustomed muscles. But the three-year deal concluded at Royal Mail – settling the most intractable dispute of recent times – shows that pragmatism is still the watchword of employee relations. British workers may need to let off steam, but they won’t be building Mediterranean-style barricades.

Comments

1. At 14:46 on 23 Mar 2010, Mike wrote:

I find it interesting that in the bulk of the opinion piece when talking about strikes and strife the term 'industrial relations' is used but when highlighting the successfull conclusion of a long-standing and very bitter dispute the language is of 'employee relations' as if Royal Mail was and is not a classic example of industrial relations practice and not some post-structuralist attempt to obfuscate the uneven relationship between capital and labour, management and workers. Let's call things what they are so we can use the rich theoretical foundations available to us in the the analysis of them.
Report this post

 
 

About the editors

Claire Churchard

Claire Churchard

News and features writer on People Management

Claire Warren

Claire Warren

The deputy editor at People Management, looking after the features section

James Brockett

James Brockett

News editor at People Management

Jill Evans

Jill Evans

Legal editor on People Management

Rob MacLachlan

Rob MacLachlan

Editor of People Management

Tim Smedley

Tim Smedley

Features writer on People Management.

Starting next month!

New CIPD Intermediate Certificate in HR Management from CIPD Training

Find out more

Employee health and
well-being

...NEW! online resources in partnership with AXA PPP healthcare

Explore the resources
Links open in new window
 
People Management neither recommends, nor is responsible for, the content of external sites listed here.
Your link here: contact the PM sales team.