Comment Comment
Comment on the blogs Log in here Become a member Register now
 
Ian Buckingham

Ian Buckingham

7 Mar 2011 | 17:29

(Maximum of 120 characters)
Articles more than one month old can be viewed only by CIPD members or PM Subscribers.

It’s no surprise that British organisations have once again been warned to double the number of women in boardrooms within five years or face government sanction. It’s in all of our interests that this happens. But unless organisations embrace culture development as a core business essential it won’t.

The elephant in the room in the boardroom debate is that men like working with men because, in the main, they know the unwritten rules and like to know where they stand. It’s unwise to disrespect or deride them for, whatever your opinion, male ingenuity is undeniable.

Despite constant attempts to re-define masculinity in a post-feminist world, men and women still have inherent and subtly different codes of behaviour, unwritten norms both genders learn through their interactions with each other whether on the sporting fields or surviving the incessant status, deference and power-based pecking orders we all encounter in the nursery, at school or at work. And these codes aren’t always compatible unless they reinforce the desired culture of the business. The problem is that not enough organisations are explicit about what that desired culture is.

Lord Davies, who has been leading an inquiry into male dominance in UK boardrooms, pulled back from the option of recommending mandatory quotas of women, but said FTSE-100 companies should aim for their boards to be 25 per cent female by 2015.

Interestingly, in explaining the decision to reject quotas, Davies said that only 11 per cent of the submissions received by his inquiry supported them. Yet nearly 90 per cent of overall respondents were women. Clearly women appreciate as much as their male counterparts that the answer lies in re-configuring the cultural norms within businesses rather than attacking them.

In the debates that are periodically stirred up by this persistent topic, critics variously blame blinkered chairmen recruiting in their own image; or headhunters operating behind the change curve. But seldom does the issue of culture, the way we do things within businesses, feature.

Of course, it’s ridiculous that women are still so under represented in senior roles. But outrage isn’t working and the answer doesn’t lie in imposing quotas that women themselves don’t believe in.

Surely the solution lies in acknowledging and respecting difference rather than criticising and attacking alternative approaches; in re-positioning culture change and organisation development as business critical not discretionary activities reserved for the good times. Much more can be done to champion and mentor role models from both sexes, not on the grounds of their gender, but because they exemplify the values, behaviours and culture required for businesses to thrive. And that, after all, makes good business sense.

Ian Buckingham is author of Brand Champions, published by Palgrave Macmillan

Comments

1. At 12:06 on 14 Mar 2011, Peter Spencer Copping wrote:

My model of this is simpler than 'culture change' I'm working at home and outside United Utilities are renewing Manchester 130 year old pipes. So HR has to look at the national talent pipe for board level and senior executives, and find out how it works and where it leaks or is diverted. I expect myself the filter beds are fixed even if enough talent starts of from the start. (in Manchester's water case The Lakes)

These positions attract high rewards and are limited in number so men and their networks have a high incentive to fix it. I assume women are as good as men, so the selection is tighter for both men and woment under equal ops . More able people on boards results. but less men.( if selection is any good)

It's freaky economics.
Report this post

2. At 10:07 on 30 Mar 2011, Joanne Heath wrote:

The elephant in the room, in my opinion, is that things won't change unless we set quotas. Working, as I do, in a male dominated business, I know that the last thing on the Board meeting agenda is "we must appoint a female Director". Yes, it may well be a question of culture but the one won't change without the other.
Report this post

 
 

About the specialists

Iain Mackinnon

Iain Mackinnon

Managing director of the Mackinnon Partnership and a public policy consultant specialising in the people side of economic development,...

Ian Buckingham

Ian Buckingham

A specialist in employee engagement. He is the former founding MD of Interbrand Inside and the founder of the Bring Yourself 2 Work...

John Philpott

John Philpott

Chief economic adviser at the CIPD and visiting professor of economics at the University of Hertfordshire. He has been an adviser to...

John Taylor

John Taylor

John Taylor is the chief executive of Acas

Lou Burrows

Lou Burrows

Global head of people at innovation company ?What If! Since joining in 2006 Lou has revolutionised the company's approach to recruitment,...

Peter Honey

Peter Honey

Founder of Peter Honey Publications Ltd. He created the Honey & Mumford Learning Styles Questionnaire and has worked as a management...

Peter Reid

Peter Reid

European Employee Relations Consultant who has monitored employment developments in Brussels for almost 20 years. Peter also advises...

Richard Goff

Richard Goff

Richard Goff is one of the CIPD's Relationship Managers, concentrating particularly on relationships with HR Leaders and engaging them...

The Apprentice

The Apprentice

Jo Cameron is a former contestant on The Apprentice and founder of training and development company Jo Cameron’s High Performance Academy....

Starting next month!

New CIPD Intermediate Certificate in HR Management from CIPD Training

Find out more

Employee health and
well-being

...NEW! online resources in partnership with AXA PPP healthcare

Explore the resources
Links open in new window
 
People Management neither recommends, nor is responsible for, the content of external sites listed here.
Your link here: contact the PM sales team.